I chose Tie because both reconstructions look almost the same as the original video. The fire, trees, motion, and timing match very closely in both clips, and I could not find a clear difference large enough to prefer one.
I selected Tie since both reconstructed videos appear nearly identical to the original footage. The flames, foliage, movement, and temporal sequencing align remarkably well in each version, making it impossible for me to identify any significant distinctions that would favor one over the other.